Vargo's Buffalo Style Pizza
Authentic fresh-made pizza. Dine in, take out, or delivered to your door.
Our Story
Welcome to Vargo's Buffalo Style Pizza
At Vargo's Buffalo Style Pizza, we pride ourselves on creating authentic fresh made pizza. Our passion for quality ingredients and traditional recipes has been the cornerstone of our family-owned restaurant since day one.
Buffalo Style Pizza
Dine In · Take Out · Delivery
Order your favorite pie fresh-made to order. We deliver right to your door.
What Our Customers Say
Allison Kelkites
August 3, 2026
Elizabeth McElheny
July 26, 2026
Great people and great food, but always a long wait. No matter the day of the week.
D Wilcox
July 20, 2026
Good stuff!!!
Lynn Wilcox
June 27, 2026
So grateful to have found this gem in steinhatchee. The sauce is home! Love everything fresh NY style. Ate here twice while visiting.
Steve Eichler
June 19, 2026
Coming from outside of Buffalo, the pizza and wings very good. Great sized wings, good sauces, excellent white pizza. It's hard to find good white pizza in Florida. The staff was friendly and quick.
Bernadette McClellan
May 25, 2026
Our pizza and garlic cheese bread was amazing. It took us a little while to get it, but I understood it was them and they were so sweet and apologized. Definitely will be back.
Visit Us
Questions? We're Here to Help.
Whether you want to book an RV space, store your boat or trailer, or have questions about an upcoming event — give us a call or drop us a line and we'll get back to you soon.